Handling Criticism: Advice for Life

woman with guitar

There have been a couple of very important people in my professional life who taught me the importance of not giving two craps about negativity that doesn’t offer any kind of insight into how you can improve. Here are the lessons I’ve learned. I hope they help you, too.

moving truckThe “Move On” Perspective

When I worked for a media outlet, I received all kinds of email messages and phone calls critiquing everything from the pitch of my voice to the way I pronounced certain words to the way I wrote my news stories. (My favorite phone call came from a guy who swore I was saying the word “inclement” incorrectly. He insisted I needed to put the emphasis on the second syllable instead of the first. Say it out loud that way. It sounds weird. For the record, both ways are correct.)

The fearless leader of our station advised me to listen to all the feedback I received, evaluate it, take anything that’s potentially helpful, and forget about the rest. What I like about this approach is that you give the other person the basic courtesy of listening to them. But the best part is possibly gleaning something useful from their critique, no matter how tactlessly it’s delivered. Taking this attitude instantly removes defensiveness. This approach allows you to view feedback as an opportunity to get better, discard anything that isn’t helpful, and move on.

shrugThe “You Can’t Please Everyone” Attitude

One time, a woman called our station. She complained to our fearless leader that we repeated some of our programming. Our leader’s response? Turn off the radio! I absolutely love this because it shows that one person’s gripe didn’t undermine our long-standing commitment to a broadcast schedule that aimed to serve our audience well and get the most bang for our programming buck. This one person’s habit of listening to the radio for hours at a time was unusual. We know from research that most people tune in and out of programs as they go through their day. So, we didn’t let this one person’s gripe cause us to change course. And I love how devoid of defensiveness the response is: don’t like what we’re doing? Go someplace else.

keytarThe “It’s Not a Commentary on You as a Person” Mentality

If someone doesn’t like your writing, your keytar playing in a field of horses, or anything else you do, remember that the critique is about that isolated thing, not you as a person. If their negative feedback is framed as a personal attack, then the problem is theirs, not yours. I’ve found the people who squawk the loudest in degrading others often have the lowest self-esteem.

Remember, you’ve accomplished something extraordinary: you’ve written a novel, composed a song, performed a role, or achieved some other feat that few others have. That, in and of itself, is enough to make you proud, regardless of what mud someone might sling at you. So, go ahead. Play the heck out of that keytar.

Top image via Flickr by xlordashx

Animated gifs via Giphy

2 thoughts on “Handling Criticism: Advice for Life

  1. Thought this was great, really helpful stuff. I did laugh though at the image of the dude who kept calling in specially to (mis?)correct your pronunciation.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Yes! I did feel better after the conversation to know that he and I were both right. But to my ears, saying his way sounded really odd.🙂 Glad this was helpful!

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s